Should the classroom stock silk, marble, wood-fill, and dual-color filament?
Our position, and the 'novelty sparks engagement' counterpoint.
Our position
Silk-finish, marble-effect, wood-fill, dual-color coextrusion - these exist and some are gorgeous. They also cost 2x-4x basic PLA, clog hotends faster, and kids printing a name tag do not see the difference. One roll as a novelty for a specific project is fine. Stocking the cart with premium filament wastes budget that should go to consumable volume.
Other voices
Reputable sources worth reading before you decide. Labels reflect our honest read of each source's general stance, not direct quotes.
Filament-comparison YouTube channels
Broadly agreesSide-by-side tests consistently show that specialty PLA is more finicky and the aesthetic benefit is project-specific, not always visible.
Single-novelty-roll advocates
Nuanced / mixedKeeping one roll of silk or wood-fill for specific projects is reasonable. Stocking a cart with it is not.
Art-focused programs
Pushes backPrograms with an art / craft focus can use specialty filament as the main learning medium. Different goals, different stock.